Jefferson Mansfield Smith.
That was the name of my maternal grandmother’s great first love, per my fractured childhood memories of my mother’s stories. As I got older and learned the truth about lots of family history, I also learned this: My mother and reality sometimes didn’t get along. I don’t think she was intentionally being dishonest. I think for her it was about telling a good story. Why let the facts get in the way, right?
Because of one of her oft-told tales, I’ve always associated Jefferson Mansfield Smith, a soldier in the war to end all wars, with Veterans Day in general and my family in particular. I know very little about this triple-named gentleman. I’ve never seen his picture. Never learned how he and my grandmother met. Never once, while she was still alive heard her mention his name. I don’t really truly know the nature of their relationship. Yet, because of my mother’s stories, every November I think of him with a profound sense of sadness and I wonder about what could have been.
My grandmother emigrated to the United States from Ireland sometime before World War 1. For years my mother insisted that my grandmother was only fourteen when she came here all alone. My mother and I would have intense, emotional discussions about how awful that must have been. We conjured up elaborate scenarios where my grandmother was wrenched from her parents’ arms while sobbing hysterically, clothing rendered to rags and all that, forced onto a rickety, leaking coffin ship, the stench of death everywhere. We marveled that she survived the month-long crossing of the angry Atlantic, in the dark, dank, disease-riddled confine that was the steerage section.
A couple of decades back, a cousin did some research, and we learned how mistaken we were. Our grandmother was probably in her early twenties when she emigrated, not barely a teen. She traveled with a friend, not alone. By the time of my grandmother’s voyage, steerage, and the deaths and illnesses associated with it, was a thing of the past. My grandmother likely traveled in third class, in a dormitory-style cabin with bunkbeds. The trip was not cushy by any means, but also not the traumatic near-death experience my mother and I had called forth.
By 1918, my grandmother had established a life for herself. She was working as a maid for a wealthy family in Holyoke, MA, a thriving industrial town teeming with Irish immigrants, in the western part of the state. That same year, she got her high school diploma from Holyoke High School’s evening program. That’s possibly where she met Jefferson Mansfield Smith, though we can’t be sure.
According to my mother, Jefferson was one of my grandmother’s closest friends. As a child, I took that to mean they were secretly in love. Like all the physically able young men of his generation, Jefferson was called to serve his country. He was shipped to France in the last days of the war. The story goes that he died in the hell that was the bloody, blighted Argonne Forest a heart-breaking day -- minutes perhaps, before the Armistice was signed on the 11th day of the 11thmonth at the 11th hour.
Teaching kids about holidays can be challenging. Given the constraints of the curriculum, there’s never enough time to really get thorough and deep. Most kids I’ve met look at most school holidays simply as an opportunity to sleep in late and play on their phones all day. When it comes to days like Memorial Day and Veterans Day, this makes me uncomfortable, and I always tried to find ways to bring the reality of the reason for these holidays into the classroom. The themes of love and loss, the wouldas, couldas, shouldas of life, grab kids and hold them and make them think about things in new ways.
I think that’s why I always told my students about Jefferson Mansfield Smith around Veterans Day and how his sacrifice in the brutality that was the Argonne Forest in 1918 changed everything for my grandmother, and, by extension, for me and my family.
I’d set the stage by telling the students about my immigrant grandmother working as a maid and going to school at night, then mention her potentially romantic relationship with Jefferson Mansfield Smith, how he and all the young men his age went overseas to war, then about the heartbreaking timing of his heroic death. We’d discuss how the death of one person, one soldier can change everything. How, if he’d lived, perhaps my grandmother would have stayed in Holyoke, married at a younger age, had a dozen or more kids, like many of her friends.
I explained how my grandmother eventually moved from Holyoke to another city. Time passed. She got older and resigned herself to the reality that she’d likely never marry, never have children. Then, in her late 30s, a decade after her young friend’s death, she found love once more, married, then miraculously had not one, not two, but four healthy children.
But what about her friend who gave up everything for this patriotic crusade? What about his family? I’d tell them I didn’t know and sometimes we’d look him up online. We never found anything though.
Even now, every November out of curiosity, I google the name “Jefferson Mansfield Smith.” Always nothing. No obituary notice, draft card, census entry, possible relatives. Nada. Zilch. It's depressing, how easy it is for humans beings to simply disappear.
Sometimes I wonder if he ever really existed. I’d questioned my mother about this many times and she always swore that, as a girl, she remembered many family day trips to Holyoke, where she’d seen with her own eyes his name etched on the city’s World War 1 Memorial. Still, now, with all this modern technology, with so many infinite worlds of knowledge at our literal fingertips, why couldn’t I find his name?
Yesterday, finally, I did.
More later.